Craig's List: Adam Fantilli, Leo Carlsson jostle for 2nd behind Connor Bedard in NHL Draft ranking

Regina Pats centre Connor Bedard is the runaway favourite to be selected No. 1 overall in the 2023 NHL Draft, but the No. 2 spot is open for discussion in the eyes of TSN Director of Scouting Craig Button.

Button has University of Michigan centre Adam Fantilli at No. 2 after a fantastic freshman season for the Wolverines. The Nobleton, Ont., product has 29 goals and 64 points in 35 games and is a favourite for the Hobey Baker Award as the top NCAA men’s hockey player. He also had five points in seven games to help Canada win gold at the 2023 World Juniors.

However, Button says Fantilli has competition at No. 2 in Orebro forward Leo Carlsson, who occupies the No. 3 spot.

Carlsson had 10 goals and 25 points in 44 games playing in Sweden’s top league this season along with five assists in five playoff games. He had three goals and three assists as Sweden finished fourth at the 2023 World Juniors.

“Fantilli generates offence through the skating and that drive,” said Button. “Carlsson has imagination and playmaking qualities, puck skills. They’re different players.

“I think Carlsson has a lot of what [Washington Capitals centre] Nicklas Backstrom has.”

Russian forward Matvei Michkov slides up one spot to No. 4 in the March edition of Button’s list. Still regarded as the draft’s biggest wild card due to his passport and contract situation, Michkov has continued to demonstrate why he is one of the best prospects in the draft this season. With KHL club HK Sochi, the 18 year old had nine goals and 20 points in 27 games.

Dropping back to the No. 5 position is Czech winger Eduard Sale. Playing in the Czech Extraliga with HC Kometa Brno, he had seven goals and 14 points in 43 regular-season games this season. Despite sliding back one spot, Button compares Sale to a current Czech superstar skating in the NHL with the Boston Bruins.

“I think he's a classic case of David Pastrnak,” said Button. “And whether I'm right or I’m wrong, I'm not going to make that mistake.

“I've watched David play since he was 14 because he played with William Nylander in Sodertalje, so I was able to get to watch him play. He ended with a bad back in his draft year, didn't play all that well. Then he ends up [going in] the 20s. [Now] he's one of the best players in the league. That's how I feel about Eduard Sale.

“I see too much high end ability and potential for Eduard Sale to base anything on stats in the Extraliga. He's too good.”

Making his debut appearance in the first round on Button’s list is Fantilli’s Michigan teammate Gavin Brindley at No. 23. Standing at 5-foot-9 and 157 pounds, he has 12 goals and 38 points in 40 games as a freshman on a stacked Michigan roster. He was also one of three draft-eligible players to make the American World Juniors squad that earned bronze.

“Smaller players have to show me that they have unique qualities,” said Button. “His game has grown massively since the World Juniors.

“Three things: His brains – he’s exceptionally dialled in, understands the game in every regard. His quickness – he’s quick in his speed, quick in his hands. And he’s a massive competitor.”

Bedard’s final totals to end the 2022-23 WHL regular season are 71 goals, 72 assists and 143 points in 57 games. In comparison, Sidney Crosby recorded 66 goals and 168 points in 62 games with the QMJHL’s Rimouski Oceanic in 2004-05.

After three seasons in the WHL with 134 games played, Bedard finishes as a goal-per-game player with 134 goals and averaging two points per game with 271 points. 

“It’s the best season by a draft-eligible player since Sidney Crosby in 2005,” said Button. “The best. Nobody’s even close. Not [Connor] McDavid. Nobody. And like Crosby, his impact can be immediate in the NHL.”

RK Player Team POS
1 Connor Bedard Regina (WHL) C
2 Adam Fantilli Michigan (NCAA) C
3 Leo Carlsson Örebro (SHL) C
4 Matvei Michkov St. Petersburg (KHL) RW
5 Eduard Sale Brno (CZE) LW
6 Will Smith USA NTDP (USHL) C
7 Colby Barlow Owen Sound (OHL) LW
8 Zach Benson Winnipeg (WHL) LW
9 Andrew Cristall Kelowna (WHL) LW/RW
10 Axel Sandin-Pellikka Skelleftea (SWE J20) D
11 Gabe Perreault USA NTDP (USHL) LW
12 Brayden Yager Moose Jaw (WHL) C
13 Ryan Leonard USA NTDP (USHL) RW
14 Oliver Moore USA NTDP (USHL) C
15 Ethan Gauthier Sherbrooke (QMJHL) C
16 Tom Willander Rogle (SWE J20) D
17 Nate Danielson Brandon (WHL) C
18 Matthew Wood Connecticut (NCAA) RW
19 Dalibor Dvorsky AIK (SWE-Als) C
20 Koehn Ziemmer Prince George (WHL) RW
21 Riley Heidt Prince George (WHL) C
22 Samuel Honzek Vancouver (WHL) LW
23 Gavin Brindley Michigan (NCAA) C/RW
24 Bradley Nadeau Penticton (BCHL) RW/LW
25 Calum Ritchie Oshawa (OHL) C/RW
26 David Reinbacher Kloten (SUI) D
27 Otto Stenberg Frölunda (SWE J20) LW
28 Quentin Musty Sudbury (OHL) C/LW
29 Etienne Morin Moncton (QMJHL) D
30 Mathieu Cataford Halifax (QMJHL) C/RW
31 Mikhail Gulyayev Omsk (MHL) D
32 Kasper Halttunen HIFK (SM Liiga) RW
33 Gracyn Sawchyn Seattle (WHL) C
34 Roman Kantserov Magnitogorsk (MHL) RW
35 Lukas Dragicevic Tri-City (WHL) D
36 Noah Dower-Nilsson Frölunda (SWE J20) LW
37 Oliver Bonk London (OHL) D
38 Carson Bjarnason Brandon (WHL) G
39 Jesse Kiiskanen Pelicans (SM Liiga Jr) RW
40 Jason Shaugabay Warroad High (USHS) RW
41 Nick Lardis Hamilton (OHL) LW
42 Caden Price Kelowna (WHL) D
43 Aydar Suniev Penticton (BCHL) LW
44 Danny Nelson USA NTDP (USHL) LW
45 Emil Jarventie Ilves (SM Liiga) LW
46 Lenni Hameenaho Pori (SM Liiga) RW
47 Anton Wahlberg Malmo (SWE J20) C/LW
48 Coulson Pitre Flint (OHL) RW
49 Daniil But Yaroslavl (MHL) LW
50 Nico Myatovic Seattle (WHL) LW
51 Kalan Lind Red Deer (WHL) LW
52 Tanner Moldendyk Saskatoon (WHL) D
53 Hunter Brzustewicz Kitchener (OHL) D
54 Carson Rehkopf Kitchener (OHL) LW
55 Andrew Strathman Tri-City (USHL) D
56 Charlie Stramel Wisconsin (NCAA) C/RW
57 Aram Minnetian USA NTDP (USHL) D
58 Michael Hrabal Omaha (USHL) G
59 Alex Ciernik Sodertalje (SWE J20) RW
60 Trey Augustine USA NTDP (USHL) G
61 Ethan Miedema Windsor (OHL) LW
62 Jayden Perron Chicago (USHL) RW
63 Andrew Gibson S.S. Marie (OHL) D
64 Rasmus Kumpulainen Pelicans (SM Liiga Jr) C
65 Scott Ratzlaff Seattle (WHL) G
66 Dmitri Simashev Yaroslavl (MHL) D
67 David Edstrom Frölunda (SWE J20) C
68 Cam Squires Cape Breton (QMJHL) RW
69 Brad Gardiner Ottawa (OHL) C
70 Maxim Strbak Sioux Falls (USHL) D
71 Luca Cagnoni Portland (WHL) D
72 Connor Levis Kamloops (WHL) C
73 Carey Terrance Erie (OHL) C
74 Adam Gajan Chippewa (NAHL) G
75 Noel Nordh Brynäs (SWE J20) LW
76 Beau Akey Barrie (OHL) D
77 Jakub Dvorak Liberec (CZE) D
78 Cameron Allen Guelph (OHL) D
79 Tyler Peddle Drummondville (QMJHL) LW
80 Theo Lindstein Brynäs (SWE J20) D