MLB
Toronto Blue JaysOpens in new window
New York MetsOpens in new window
Tarik SkubalOpens in new window

Skubal will end up in New York, says Olney: Mets will put ‘Biggest offer on the table’

Published: 

Tarik Skubal, the top lefty in baseball and the biggest name on the free-agent market by a long shot, is expected to make his decision soon - and it looks like there’s a front runner in the New York Mets.

Recent reports have indicated that the final decision will be between the Mets and the Toronto Blue Jays, but ESPN’s Buster Olney has full confidence that Skubal will ultimately choose the Mets.

Olney joined First Up on TSN1050 on Thursday morning to discuss the pitcher and the negotiation between the teams involved.

“The only chance the Blue Jays land Skubal is if Tarik Skubal, for whatever reason, decides ‘I don’t want to pitch in New York,’” Olney said. “Because I do think the Mets are going to put the biggest offer on the table.”

Skubal, who turns 30 on Friday, is expected to receive the biggest contract given to a starting pitcher in MLB history whenever he makes his decision.

The fire-balling lefty earned back-to-back Cy Young awards in 2024 and 2025 while a member of the Detroit Tigers, and delivered another dominant season split between the Tigers and Los Angeles Dodgers in 2026, despite missing over a month due to minor elbow surgery.

This MLB off-season is rife with uncertainty with a lockout looming, as the owners are steadfast on the implementation of a salary cap, while the MLB Player’s Association is adamant in the opposite direction.

Olney notes that the salary cap will definitely be a factor in the negotiations, for both the high-spending Mets and Blue Jays.

“A lot of teams, because of this looming possibility of the salary cap, they’re like ‘we don’t want to get into this bidding for this huge contract, because we don’t know what the salary cap is going to look like. That system hasn’t been defined yet, and we don’t want to take on that deal,’” Olney said.

“If the Blue Jays sit [out], that would be a reasonable thought, because you’ve got [first baseman] Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s contract, which is a lot (14 years, $500 million), with the salary cap potentially being at like $265 million, if that’s what happens, it’s a little scary.”

The Blue Jays have cultivated a strong reputation around the league for being a destination players love - many veteran pitchers, including Kevin Gausman and Chris Bassitt, among others - have made their love of the city and team known even after departing.

It may take a pitch along that vein from the Blue Jays to win over Skubal.

“If the Blue Jays are competitive with their offer, if they’re close, I do wonder if Skubal might say ‘I want to go be Superman to Dylan Cease’s Batman, I like the idea of pitching there,’” Olney said. “The only way he doesn’t wind up with the Mets is if he decides he just doesn’t want to pitch in New York.”

This is not the first time the Mets and Blue Jays have clashed over top free agents in recent years. The Mets took home the free agency prize in 2024, nabbing outfielder Juan Soto on a record 15-year, $765 million contract, where the Blue Jays reportedly finished second at a $750 million offer.

Last off-season, the Mets landed former Blue Jays shortstop Bo Bichette on a three-year, $126 million contract after the Blue Jays were also reportedly in the running.

It sounds like the money is in favour of the Mets, where Olney ultimately thinks Skubal will land.

“[With the] history of the Scott Boras clients, and Scott’s his agent, they typically take the most money and I think the biggest offer is gonna come from the Mets. My guess is he’s gonna go to the Mets.”