Columnist image

TSN Baseball Insider

Archive

TSN Baseball Analyst Steve Phillips answers several questions surrounding the game each week. This week's topics include the reality of teh Blue Jays talent, the heir apparent to Derek Jeter as the next face of baseball, the one-game playoff game format and playoff predictions.

1) Now that we have the chance to look back over the entire season, did the 2014 Toronto Blue Jays underachieve or were they ultimately just not good enough to compete in both the American League East and in the Wild Card race? Is there one glaring change that you see that needs to be made with the team in terms of how they play or a specific position need that has to be their offseason priority as they begin to prepare for the 2015 season?
 
I don't believe that the Blue Jays underachieved this season. I believe they played to the level of the talent on their roster. They looked like an 83-win team. They played like an 83-win team. They were an 83-win team.
 
The Jays were particularly streaky over the course of the season but that wasn't completely unexpected and is definitely explainable. Teams that lack a #1 starter are prone to streaks. The Jays lack an ace. They don't have a guy who eats up 220 innings and is a +10 in his won-loss record. They don't have the leader who is the stopper. Neither Mark Buerhle nor RA Dickey are aces anymore. They are quality #3 starters. JA Happ and Drew Hutchison are #5 starters. Marcus Stroman made a nice impression in his first 20 major league starts but he isn't an ace. At least not yet.  
 
In a season in which two aces were traded, the Jays were bystanders. Jon Lester and David Price got traded during the season and could have been difference-makers for the Toronto. But alas, the Jays did not have the financial wherewithal to even try for them.  
 
The Jays bullpen was mediocre this season. Casey Janssen didn't make his first appearance until mid-May and he when he came back, he wasn't nearly as effective as he had been in previous years. He only had 28 strikeouts in 45.2 innings pitched. He had a 3.94 ERA and gave up more hits than innings pitched. The lefty relievers, Brett Cecil and Aaron Loup were more effective than the righty relievers other than rookie Aaron Sanchez, who was awesome in his first taste of the majors.  
 
When it comes to position players, the Jays really suffered with inconsistency at second base, third base and centrefield.  
 
I know that Brett Lawrie is versatile because he can play both second and third base but he is inadequate offensively at both positions. And he was better than whomever was playing the other position when he wasn't, which speaks to the significance of the weakness.
 
The centerfielders hit .213/.275/.361. That is the lowest batting average in the AL. Colby Rasmus is not a functional offensive player. He doesn't hit for enough power to warrant his low on-base percentage. Anthony Gose still hasn't proven he is a major league hitter as he hit..226/.311/.293.  
 
Every team has flaws. There are no perfect teams and no perfect players. The Jays came up short from making the playoffs this year because of one big hole in the rotation, a couple of arms in the bullpen and three offensive deficiencies.  
 
The Jays needed a #1 starter, upgrades in CF and at either second base or third base. Those are certainly needs again for next season but they will also need to add a closer and a leftfielder with the pending free agency of Casey Janssen and Melky Cabrera, respectively. Of course, this will all cost money and it may not be there. GM Alex Anthopolous has his work cut out for himself. He is going to have to get creative to reconstruct his roster in a financially responsible way.  
 
2) With Derek Jeter no longer an active Major Leaguer, is there a player that you see as either the new or next face of baseball? Is this a mantle that falls squarely to Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mike Trout or is there a more veteran player that you see stepping into that void until Mr. Trout has a little more experience and a better chance to make his legend grow?
 
In the olden days when a king died, the people would yell, "The king is dead. Long live the king." It was a statement acknowledging the departure of the king but also of the succession of his successor. Derek Jeter isn't dead by any means but he has left very big shoes to fill. His shadow at Yankee Stadium was longer than anyone. It didn't matter that A-Rod was bigger than Jeter, Derek's shadow always extended further. Jeter was the face and voice of not only the Yankees but of Major League Baseball as well. With his departure, baseball needs new leadership.
 
This offseason, baseball has been given a great gift. The playoff teams include: Pittsburgh's Andrew McCutcheon, Washington's Bryce Harper and Stephen Strasburg, Baltimore's Manny Machado (injured) and Adam Jones, the Dodgers' Yasiel Puig and Clayton Kershaw and the Angels' Mike Trout. There are certainly a few other big name young players on non-playoff teams that have sex appeal but the bulk of them are playing in October.
 
It may be asking too much for any one player to have to fill Jeter's shoes. If I had to pick one player, it would be Mike Trout because he has the ability, looks and charisma that scream superstar.  
 
Baseball has been criticized for not marketing its stars properly. Now is the time for that to be resolved. The game needs to sell fans on the quantity of young personable stars in the game now. When they are marketed in numbers, there is less pressure on any one player to be Derek Jeter perfect.  
 
We need to be introduced to the young stars in a different way. We need to learn what they are like and what makes them special and different. The more, the merrier so when any one of them takes a misstep, we still have other young stars to admire.  
 
There will never be another Derek Jeter. He was amazing on and off the field. He represented his family, the Yankee organization and the game with class and dignity. He was perfectly imperfect. I believe in the young studs in baseball today. We are very likely headed into a remarkable era of great young starts who will re-energize baseball's fanbase.  
 
3) Now that we've seen the Kansas City Royals advance over the Oakland Athletics in an extra-inning thriller and the Pittsburgh Pirates get blown out by the San Francisco Giants in the two Wild Card games, do you think that's a fair way for a team to be eliminated from the playoffs? Would baseball be better served to play a three-game series to determine the final Division series team or are you in favour of a one-game winner-take-all start to the post-season?  
 
My Mets' teams in 1999 and 2000 made the playoffs as Wild Card teams. There wasn't a second Wild Card back then so we jumped right into the Division Series and were matched against the division winner with the best record that wasn't the Braves. Back then, the Wild Card winner couldn't play the division winner from its own division in the Division Series. In both seasons, we had to play until the last day of the season to even get into the playoffs. In effect, we had been playing playoff baseball for the final few weeks of the regular season. I can make the argument that we were better prepared to compete in the NLDS than the division winners we were matched against. Division winners sometimes coast over the last week or two of the season if they clinch early. They rest their players and at times get a bit complacent and rusty. There just didn't seem to be enough of a reward for winning the division.  
 
The change in format with a second wild card winner has addressed the issue in a significant way.  The one game playoff series between wild card winners is not only appropriate and fair, it's exciting. The one-game playoff series between the two Wild Card teams creates a disadvantage as they need to pitch their best available pitcher, which is often their #1 starter. Yes, a win allows the one Wild Card team to advance but they then face the team with the best overall record in the league that has its pitching lined up the way they want it.  
 
A three-game series would actually be an advantage for the Wild Card winner as their ace would be that much closer to being ready to pitch in the Division Series than they are after the one-game series. The overall goal isn't about being fair to the Wild Card teams, it is about being fair to the division winners. I fully support the system as currently constructed.   
 
4) So here are my playoff predictions:
 
ALDS - Detroit Tigers vs. Baltimore Orioles

Despite the fact that the Orioles are off to a 1-0 lead in the series, I am picking the Tigers to win this series. I believe the Tigers starting pitching depth will prevail over the Orioles' powerful lineup.  Whereas, the Orioles pitching is a bit underrated, I believe the Tigers will beat up on the O's pitching and score a bunch of runs. Good pitching beats good hitting. The Tigers will throw more quality innings despite the bullpen issues they face. Tigers win in 5 games. Series MVP: JD Martinez
 
ALDS - Los Angeles Angels vs. Kansas City Royals

The Royals are currently riding the high of two dramatic extra-inning wins in the payoffs so far. They play good defence and have tremendous speed to help them manufacture runs. The Royals have momentum and confidence. That being said, momentum is only as good as your next day's starting pitcher and I like the pitching matchups for the Angels moving forward in the series. Look for Mike Trout and Albert Pujols to carry the load offensively. Angels in four games. Series MVP: Albert Pujols
 
NLDS - Washington Nationals vs. San Francisco Giants

The Giants advanced after defeating the Pirates in the Wild Card game. They had to burn their ace Madison Bumgarner in that matchup. The Nats get to line up the pitching they way they want, taking into account the home and road splits of their rotation. The Nationals have as balanced a team as is still alive. The Nats will win the Series in four games. Series MVP: Adam LaRoche
 
NLDS - Los Angeles Dodgers vs. St Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals are a very professional team. They do things the right way and find themselves in the playoffs what seems like every year. They were pushed until the end but held on to win the division. The Game 1 matchup with the Dodgers is the postseason's most compelling with Clayton Kershaw against Adam Wainwright. Kershaw wins Game 1 and the Dodgers sweep the series. Series MVP: Matt Kemp
 
ALCS - Detroit Tigers vs. LA Angels

This will be a great matchup of the best starting pitching against the team with the best record in th AL. The Tigers have had their number in the past and it will continue this year. The Angels won't be able to contain Miguel Cabrera as he shows Trout who is boss. Trout will erupt and respond to Cabrera but the Tigers win the series in 6 games. Series MVP: Miguel Cabrera.
 
NLCS - LA Dodgers vs .Washington Nationals

This will be an epic series. Two very evenly matched teams with deep starting pitching and young stars in the field will battle. This series will go back and forth ending in a Game 7. The Dodgers will prevail and advance to the World Series. Series MVP: Adrian Gonzalez
 
WORLD SERIES - Detroit Tigers vs. LA Dodgers

What a matchup this will be: great starting pitching and superstar players. Two teams built to win now with extraordinary talent and balance. The one area where there is a significant disparity is the bullpen. The Tigers Achilles heel all season long will show itself again. They will blow two late leads and the LA Dodgers will win the series in six games. Series MVP: Yasiel Puig